WUW:Disputes/Wikihood

Closed 13:30, 26 February 2008 (MST)

Parties Involved

• Chwoka (talk • contribs)
• Vindicator (talk • contribs)
• Znex (talk • contribs)

Judges

• Aussie Evil (talk • contribs)
• TheStick (talk • contribs)
• Sephiroth (talk • contribs)

Statements

Aussie Evil

Preliminary facts here. On 2/14/08, Vindicator deleted Wikihood and all subpages. An IP edit to the talk page of Wikihood "I've got personal reasons for removing this" [1]was made the same day, probably by Vindicator. Chwoka created two pages Wikihood 3 and Wikihood 69 in apparent retaliation. On 2/15, Chwoka edited Vindicator's replacement page (stating "Don't try anything funny here.") with jokes relating to personal attacks. Znex added to the list.

Chwoka

HAY AUSSIE CHECK YOUR E-MAIL AND COPYPASTA IT HERE KTHXBY

"Um, hello. I-is this thing on? I would like to say that Wikihood 69 was boiling in my mind before that, because I didn't like the way Wikhood was, and I checked on it, it said "Don't Try Anything Funny." I knew that he meant not to recreate Wikihood on that page, so I edited in some jokes to lighten the mood. Vindicator killed the joke maker before the punchline each time, because he told nobody to try funny stuff. It was, in no way, a personal attack. I made Wikihood 69 afterwards, as a joke about the future state of Wikihood (incredibly disorganized and unreadable). Then I decided that I wanted real Wikihood back, but I wouldn't dare do it on the Wikihood page. So, I made Wikihood 3 figuring that if Eric can make his own Wikihood (Wikihood 2), I could create my own (Wikihood 3). None of it was me hating on Vindicator." --ÆAUSSIEevilÆ^TC/☺ 21:34, 23 February 2008 (MST)

Vindicator

Wikihood has been through 6 or 7 reincarnations. The only decent one was the first. The others lacked activity or burnt to the ground via rule-breakers, out-of-H*R references (I'm pointing fingers at Noxigar and myself) and shut-down websites (the old WUW). I was sick of a reincarnating product that failed on ALL OCCASIONS. As it was my work, and as it was my decision, I saw it right to remove it, out of the creator's request. I doubt Znex played a major hand in this, and was just probably trying to add to some unwanted things. I can't say the same for Chwoka. Now I'm not saying I hate or dislike the members I am contesting with, but Chwoka: I REALLY didn't appreciate being mocked via Wikihood 69. I don't take it as a personal attack, more like mocking me as a person, how I act, how I change things. Name calling is immature, so I'm not going there. >> What I'm saying is: Wikihood's downfall is all my fault. YES, I, the one who made it, the one who started it from a video called "The Strangerhood", caused a cataclysmic downfall of the very thing I hoped would be successful.

It. Was. All. My. Fault. So if you punish anyone, if you argue to anyone, to me. Chwoka was just defending the good side of Wikihood (probably Wikihood 2 albeit outside references), and Znex really didn't do anything bad.

...Prosecution/Defense/Witness/Whoever I am rests. --«√įńđīçąŧōŗ» ^©'07 _c

Znex

Yeah, I only really just added to what Chwoka wrote on the Wikihood page. I didn't think it as bad or anything, I thought it was just some big joke. That, and I forgot that you're not supposed to edit other people's fanstuff. T_T But it wasn't really a fanstuff at the time, though, was it? By the way, I'm still blocked. T_T

Decisions

Vindicator has no votes due to conflict of interest

Request to grant hearing (5 for, 0 against, 0 abstain, 1 forbidden)

• Accept as submitted --ÆAUSSIEevilÆ^TC/☺ 16:52, 17 February 2008 (MST)
• Accept as both sides should get a say 大棒さっさと棍子 13:08, 18 February 2008 (MST)
• Accept I think that both sides should both give a good reason.
• Accept Fairness states that both should have a say. Tommyspud 13:52, 18 February 2008 (MST)
• Accept See above. from the desk of 20eric06^t-AES 13:28, 19 February 2008 (MST)

Temporary Injunctions

None

Rulings

See /Ruling Discussion for judges talk.

Vindicator made a bad decision of deleting his overly popular interactive fanstuff without the public agreeing.

Passed 3-0-0-1

Solutions and Enforcement

Vindicator is warned to consult with involved parties before deleting interactive fanstuff.

Passed 3-0-0-1